POLI 100C POLITICAL PARTIES
9 March 2006



  1. The Realignment of the 1890s

    1. The Economy and its Effect on Politics: 1866 - 1920

      1. Population Growth



      2. Economic Growth





      3. Deflation From 1866 - 1896, Inflation 1896 - 1920





      4. Industrialization





      5. The Rise of Organized Labor



      6. The Spread of the Railroad Network





        Railroads in 1890



        Railroads and the Spread of Agriculture





        Railroad Productivity



        Railroad Mileage Increased from 35,085 Miles of Mainline Track to 166,703 Miles of Mainline Track in 1890 -- more than a 4-fold Increase



      7. The Complaints of the Farmers



        1873: The Grangers Warn the Sleeping Public about the Consolidation Train





    2. The Election of 1896



    3. Summary -- Realignment of the 1890s -- Neither Party Replaced

      1. Breadth and Depth of the Underlying Grievance – Not too great. The Farmers and the Labor Unions were angry but the Bi-Metalism Issue did not have the power that Slavery had and Inflation after 1895 negated the issue.

      2. Capacity to Provoke Resistance – Farmers had many successes.

      3. Leadership – Held firm in the Republican Party but the Democratic Party was split internally.

      4. Division of Polar Forces Between the Two Parties – Affected Mainly the Democrats.

      5. Strength of Existing Party Attachments – Strong, especially for Republicans. The Silver Republicans stayed in the Party while the Gold Democrats switched to the Republican Party.

    4. SUMMARY – Realignment of the 1890s -- The Realignment Scenario

      Clearly Type 2 -- Realignment in which Neither Party is Replaced.
      The System evolves from State A to State B/C and snaps back into State A.



  2. The Realignment of the 1930s and the Modern Democrat-Republican Party System

    1. The Democrat-Republican Political Party System, 1900 - Late 1930s: Overview

      1. The Main Organizing Dimension was Economics -- The Degree of Government Intervention in the Economy

      2. The Effect of the Depression was to Shift the Entire Distribution of Voters to the Left on the Existing Dimension. Greater Control over the Economy and Direct Cash Payments to Individuals Became Accepted Policy.

      3. The Democrats Became Overwhelmingly Dominate -- The Most Lopsided Two-Party System in American History. Many Scholars Referred to it as a One-and-a-Half Party System.

    2. The Democrat-Republican Political Party System, Late 1930s - Mid-Late 1980s: Overview

      1. In 1937-38 Voting on the Fair Labor Standards Act (Minimum Wages) Opened a serious Split between Northern and Southern Democrats. Southerners did not want Southern Agriculture to be constrained by the minimum wage because many of the Laborers were Black.

      2. During the Second World War Voting on whether or not to Use Federal Law as Opposed to State Law to Determine Voter Eligibility in the Armed Forces Further Exacerbated the Split Between Northern and Southern Democrats. Southern Democrats did not want Blacks serving in the Armed Forces to be able to vote in Southern elections.

      3. This conflict culminated in the Passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, the 1965 Voting Rights Act, and the 1967 Open Housing Act. Collectively, these laws ended legal segregation.

      4. The Passage of the Civil Rights Laws triggered a slow Realignment of the White South into the Republican Party. Aided by President Richard Nixon's "Southern Strategy", the Southern states began voting for Republican Presidential candidates. Eventually Southern States began electing Republican Senators, then Republican Representatives, and finally state and local officials switched to the Republican Party.

        Regional Differences in Presidential Vote 1948 - 2004



        House: 1879 - 2005 Percent Southern Seats Held by Republicans



        Senate: 1879 - 2005 Percent Southern Seats Held by Republicans



        House: 1879 - 2005 Percent Northern and Southern Seats Held by Republicans



        Senate: 1879 - 2005 Percent Northern and Southern Seats Held by Republicans



        Republican Percentage of Seats in State Legislatures 1948 - 2004



      5. By the 1990s Civil Rights related issues became indistinguishable from economic issues in terms of the voting coalitions in Congress.

    3. Congressional Elections: 1898 - 2004
      
                       HOUSE                               SENATE
           Democrat  Republican  Other          Democrat  Republican  Other      
      1898    163       185        9               26        53        11 
      1900    153       198        5               29        56         3
      1902    178       207                        32        58           
      1904    136       250                        32        58                        
      1906    164       222                        29        61           
      1908    172       219                        32        59            
      1910    228       162        1               42        49                        
      1912    290       127       18               51        44         1             
      1914    231       193        8               56        39         1     
      1916    210       216        9               53        42         1          
      1918    191       237        7               47        48         1     
      1920    132       300        1               37        59                   
      1922    207       225        3               43        51         2     
      1924    183       247        5               40        54         1            
      1926    195       237        3               47        48         1     
      1928    167       267        1               39        56         1            
      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      1930    220       214        1               47        48         1     
      1932    313       117        5               59        36         1       
      1934    322       103       10               69        25         2     
      1936    333        89       13               75        17         4         
      1938    262       169        4               69        23         4     
      1940    267       162        6               66        28         2      
      1942    222       209        4               57        38         1     
      1944    243       190        2               57        38         1      
      1946    188       246        1               45        51                  
      1948    263       171        1               54        42               
      1950    234       199        2               48        47               
      1952    213       221        1               47        48         1     
      1954    232       203                        48        47         1    
      1956    234       201                        49        47                        
      1958    283       154                        64        34                  
      1960    263       174                        64        36                    
      1962    258       176        1               67        33                      
      1964    295       140                        68        32                       
      1966    248       187                        64        36                      
      1968    243       192                        58        42                      
      1970    255       180                        55        45                         
      1972    243       192                        57        43                          
      1974    291       144                        61        38                         
      1976    292       143                        62        38                         
      1978    277       158                        59        41                         
      1980    243       192                        47        53                           
      1982    269       166                        46        54                         
      1984    253       182                        47        53                         
      1986    258       177                        55        45                         
      1988    259       174                        55        45                         
      1990    267       167        1               56        44                         
      1992    258       176        1               57        43                         
      1994    204       230        1               47        53                         
      1996    207       227        1               45        55                         
      1998    211       223        1               45        55                         
      2000    212       221        2               50        50                         
      2002    205       229        1               48        51         1            
      2004    201       232        1               44        55         1             
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    4. Presidential Elections: 1900 - 2004
      
                         Democrat                         Republican                          Other
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      1900    Bryan      155  6,357,698 45.5     McKinley   292  7,219,193 51.7
      1904    Parker     140  5,083,501 37.6     Roosevelt  336  7,625,599 56.4
      1908    Bryan      162  6,406,874 43.0     Taft       321  7,676,598 51.6 
      1912    Wilson     435  6,294,326 41.8     Taft         8  3,486,343 23.2    Roosevelt     88  4,120,207 27.4
      1916    Wilson     277  9,126,063 49.2     Hughes     254  8,547,039 46.1
      1920    Cox        127  9,134,074 34.2     Harding    404 16,151,916 60.3
      1924    Davis      136  8,386,532 28.8     Coolidge   382 15,724,310 54.0    La Follette   13  4,827,184 16.6
      1928    Smith       87 15,004,336 40.8     Hoover     444 21,432,823 58.2
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      1932    Roosevelt  472 22,818,740 57.4     Hoover      59 15,760,425 39.6
      1936    Roosevelt  523 27,750,866 60.8     Landon       8 16,679,683 36.5
      1940    Roosevelt  449 27,343,218 54.7     Willkie     82 22,334,940 44.8
      1944    Roosevelt  432 25,612,610 53.4     Dewey       99 22,021,053 45.9
      1948    Truman     303 24,105,810 49.5     Dewey      189 21,970,064 45.1    Thurmond      39  1,169,114  2.4
      1952    Stevenson   89 27,314,992 44.4     Eisenhower 442 33,777,945 54.9
      1956    Stevenson   73 26,022,752 42.0     Eisenhower 457 35,590,472 57.4
      1960    Kennedy    303 34,226,731 49.7     Nixon      219 34,108,157 49.5
      1964    Johnson    486 43,129,566 61.1     Goldwater   52 27,178,188 38.5
      1968    Humphrey   191 31,275,166 42.7     Nixon      301 31,785,480 43.4    Wallace       46  9,906,473 13.5
      1972    McGovern    17 29,170,383 37.5     Nixon      520 47,169,911 60.7
      1976    Carter     297 40,830,763 50.1     Ford       240 39,147,793 48.0
      1980    Carter      49 35,483,883 41.0     Reagan     489 43,904,153 50.7    Anderson       0  5,720,060  6.6
      1984    Mondale     13 37,577,185 40.6     Reagan     525 54,455,075 58.8
      1988    Dukakis    111 41,809,074 45.6     Bush,HW    426 48,886,097 53.4
      1992    Clinton    370 44,909,326 43.0     Bush,HW    168 39,103,882 37.4    Perot          0 19,741,657 18.9
      1996    Clinton    379 47,402,357 49.2     Dole       159 39,198,755 40.7    Perot          0  8,085,402  8.4
      2000    Gore       266 50,992,335 48.4     Bush       271 50,455,156 47.9    Nader          0  2,882,738  2.7
      2004    Kerry      251 59,026,013 48.3     Bush       286 62,025,554 50.7
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    5. The Economy and its Effect on Politics After 1920

      1. The 1920s Boom and the Stock Market Crash of 1929



      2. Summary of Economic Indicators during the Great Depression



      3. Unemployment (Yearly): 1929 - 2004